Modern Family has often faced criticism for its handling of the kids’ character development, with all the younger characters receiving underwhelming arcs. However, the most notable case is that of the Dunphy sisters, Haley and Alex Dunphy, portrayed by Sarah Hyland and Ariel Winter, respectively.
Both sisters initially showed great potential, maintaining a strong character presence for much of the series. However, many fans have expressed disappointment in how their growth ultimately fell short of expectations. Despite that, Haley’s character arc, though flawed, still felt more natural compared to Alex’s.
Haley Dunphy’s character growth was overshadowed by Alex’s arc in Modern Family
Haley (Sarah Hyland) and Alex Dunphy (Ariel Winter) were introduced as a typical sister duo in the hit sitcom Modern Family, often clashing over trivial matters in a competitive yet entertaining dynamic.
As the series progressed, their relationship became more relatable, with the two gradually bonding over unexpected experiences and learning to appreciate their differences. However, despite this evolution, both characters’ individual growth left much to be desired.
Fans had hoped that Haley, known for her street smarts and a keen eye for fashion and photography, would pursue a successful career in her passions. Instead, her character took an unexpected turn in the later seasons, as she rekindled her relationship with Dylan, became pregnant, and transitioned into motherhood.
Similarly, Alex’s character arc faced criticism, particularly for its incomplete resolution. One of the biggest disappointments was her abrupt romance with Arvin, which felt rushed and lacked proper development. Her decision to join him for research in Switzerland seemed out of place, making their last-minute relationship feel forced rather than organic.
While Alex’s storyline remained unresolved by the finale, Haley at least received a more well-rounded conclusion. Despite being the more reckless sibling early on, she ended up happy with a family, and a job, showcasing some level of stability and growth.
Though her ending may not have lived up to fans’ expectations, it was still a more natural and realistic progression compared to the direction Alex’s character took.
Fans admire Haley Dunphy’s organic character development in Modern Family
Fans of Modern Family have long expressed dissatisfaction with Haley Dunphy’s character arc. However, many argue that she had the most natural and realistic development and conclusion in the series.
Fans further asserted their arguments in a Reddit discussion over the unpopular opinions of the beloved Modern Family character. “She’s honestly the one you’re most likely to meet,” one fan said arguing,
Haley was most consistent and through smaller changes, had the most natural development for any character in the entire series.
Meanwhile, fans criticized Alex Dunphy’s storyline, particularly her rushed development and romance with Arvin. Despite being the most intelligent and accomplished of the Dunphy siblings, many felt that Alex’s arc was underwhelming.
Comment
byu/BigBoobieBillie from discussion
inModern_Family
Comment
byu/BigBoobieBillie from discussion
inModern_Family
Comment
byu/BigBoobieBillie from discussion
inModern_Family
Comment
byu/BigBoobieBillie from discussion
inModern_Family
Comment
byu/BigBoobieBillie from discussion
inModern_Family
“She may not be the smartest, richest, or most successful but she’s definitely the most happiest,” another fan remarked noting, “I hate what they did to Alex.”
While some found Haley’s journey underwhelming, many praised it as the most authentic and relatable. They pushed back against the expectation that she should have been a symbol of an empowering woman, instead highlighting how her story reflects the unpredictability of real life.
Modern Family is available to watch on Hulu.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire
