If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.
Making a matte lip last all day is often more work than it seems. You need lip liner to prevent feathering, a steady hand for precise application, and, before all that, soft, exfoliated lips to stop the color from flaking off midday. And let’s not forget about those inevitable touchups. Many beauty lovers turn to luxury brands like Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk to make matte lipstick less of a high-maintenance commitment. While the color is stunning, we get it — paying $30+ for a lipstick makes it more of a “once in a while” splurge than an everyday go-to.
Fortunately, there’s a wallet-friendly alternative for fans of that luxe matte finish: Maybelline Super Stay Ink Crayon Lipstick. At just $11, it’s been hailed by customers as a lookalike for the viral favorite, delivering the same gorgeous vibe without the luxury price tag.
“This is a serious [lookalike] for Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk!” one beauty enthusiast shared. “And it’s much longer lasting.” And that’s not an exaggeration — many reviewers gush about the lip color’s staying power, with one adding, “I can put this on in the morning, and it lasts through my lunch and then almost to dinner.” Smudge-resistant and fade-proof, this lipstick crayon holds up against multiple meals (and more). Plus, its creamy glide-on application means no tugging, just smooth, even color.
Even better? It’s practical. Thanks to the matte lipstick’s built-in sharpener, “you can easily line and fill without the hassle.” And speaking of multitasking, another fan noted, “I love the glide-on crayon stick — it makes it easy to line with the same product!” No need to juggle a separate liner for your perfect pout.
“Love! This is the best Charlotte Tilbury [lookalike] ever!” Shared another satisfied customer, who was digging the shade Trust Your Gut. But it’s not just the color match that wins hearts — shoppers say the matte lipstick is also incredibly comfortable. “[It] goes on like butter, yet dries to a durable, all-day consistency,” a shopper shared. Plus, it’s forgiving on mature lips. “If you’re grandma age like me, you’ll appreciate that this product doesn’t creep into lip lines. I get a crisp, defined lip and color all day.”
At $11, Maybelline Super Stay Ink Crayon Lipstick isn’t just a steal — it’s a little luxury you can afford every day. Shoppers swear it lets you have your Pillow Talk moment without the Pillow Talk price. Why not give a shade or two a try?
Before you go, check out our slideshow below:
